[REVIEW] STAR TREK: DISCOVERY’s Mid-Season Premiere “Despite Yourself”

Frakes Aptly Continues Discovery‘s Ever-intriguing Plot With an Adventure in the Mirror Universe

With the one-and-only Jonathan Frakes at the helm for “Despite Yourself,” Star Trek: Discovery continued to explore increasingly intriguing plot threads, provide some truly well-performed character moments, and throw in a callback to some serious Star Trek continuity. Cool stuff.

Let’s get into it.

The biggest surprise of the episode wasn’t even that we finally learn that the Discovery was indeed thrown into the Mirror Universe at the end of “Into the Forest I Go.” There were plenty of hints for that. No, this episode saw the death of the Discovery’s resident doctor, Hugh Culber, at the hands of an increasingly unstable Ash Tyler. The actual death itself was shocking, but it was the lead-up to it that was particularly noteworthy. The scene featured fantastic acting from Shazad Latif, who has consistently portrayed Tyler’s PTSD struggle with unrelenting intensity and realism. Tyler’s reaction to the mental and physical ways in which the Klingons altered him was bone-chilling, and it makes you feel real sympathy for Tyler’s struggle. This episode strongly hinted that Voq has in some way manifested himself in Tyler… but we’ll have to wait to learn exactly how.

Shazad Latif as Lieutenant Ash Tyler, Sonequa Martin-Green of First Officer Michael Burnham and Jason Isaacs as Captain Gabriel Lorca
Shazad Latif as Lieutenant Ash Tyler, Sonequa Martin-Green of First Officer Michael Burnham and Jason Isaacs as Captain Gabriel Lorca (CBS)

Elsewhere on Discovery, a startling revelation in the Mirror Universe is that Sylvia Tilly is the captain of the I.S.S. Discovery, which unsurprisingly is a shock to Tilly herself. After an awkward exchange between Tilly and another Mirror Universe captain, a scene played superbly by Mary Wiseman, Tilly quickly adjusts to the role of a ruthless Terran captain, perhaps faster than what we would expect. It’ll be interesting to see how she continues her role as Discovery’s captain while Lorca and Burnham are on the Mirror Shenzhou.

Jason Isaacs as Captain Gabriel Lorca, Sonequa Martin-Green of First Officer Michael Burnham and Shazad Latif as Lieutenant Ash Tyler
Jason Isaacs as Captain Gabriel Lorca, Sonequa Martin-Green of First Officer Michael Burnham and Shazad Latif as Lieutenant Ash Tyler (CBS)

Possibly the best part of the episode for die-hard fans was the use of the U.S.S. Defiant as a plot point once again. We previously knew of the Defiant back in The Original Series episode “The Tholian Web,” where the ship crossed into the Mirror Universe using techno-blabby sci-fi magic. Much later on Star Trek: Enterprise, the Defiant was the focus of a Mirror Universe two-parter, which ultimately saw the ship captured by the Terran Empire and commanded by Hoshi Sato, who proclaimed herself the new emperor thanks to the power granted by the Constitution-class ship. Now, it’ll be interesting to see how the Defiant was used in the years between that Enterprise episode and “Despite Yourself.” On a similar note, we know through a bit of throwaway dialogue that the Terran Empire encountered by the Discovery crew is led by a “faceless emperor.” What happened to Hoshi? Or will the new emperor, if we ever see him or her, be a character the Discovery crew knows?

Shazad Latif as Lieutenant Ash Tyler, Sonequa Martin-Green of First Officer Michael Burnham and Jason Isaacs as Captain Gabriel Lorca
Shazad Latif as Lieutenant Ash Tyler, Sonequa Martin-Green of First Officer Michael Burnham and Jason Isaacs as Captain Gabriel Lorca (CBS)

In the end, it is clear Frakes was charged with directing an important episode of Discovery – important both for its plot progression and character development, and he utilized his considerable directorial experience well. “Despite Yourself” gets the second half of Discovery off to a great start, and it seems like we’ll be in the Mirror Universe for a while. The Mirror Universe is certainly an aspect of Star Trek canon that deserves to be expanded, it’s what has happened in the MIrror Universe. Discovery joins The Original Series, Deep Space Nine, and Star Trek: Enterprise, as well as a host of books, comics, and games, that explore the area through the looking glass. We’ll see what new discoveries await our crew.

Stray thoughts from “Despite Yourself”:

  • Check out the fancy new worker bee. A bit more high-tech than what we see in The Motion Picture, yeah?
  • Why didn’t we actually see the Cooper come assist the Discovery? It was a bit jarring not having that scene-setting shot.
  • Cool shot of Discovery changing its registry number to read I.S.S.
    Awesome tough-guy moment from Lorca when he bashes his head on the door to sell the captive bit.
  • Lorca seems as confused as anyone to be in the Mirror Universe, which goes against the theory that he sent the ship there at the end of the previous episode. Or is this still all part of his plan? Hope that Agony booth was worth it!

What do you think of Discovery’s return episode? Let us know in the comments!


TrekNews.net is your dedicated source for all the latest news on Star Trek: Discovery. Follow @TrekNewsnet on Twitter, TrekNews on Facebook, @TrekNews on Instagram and TrekNewsnet on YouTube.


Try CBS All Access for Free

Interested in signing up for CBS All Access to check out Star Trek: Discovery for yourself? Click here to receive a one-week free trial.

Kyle Hadyniak has been a lifelong Star Trek fan. A graduate student at the University of Maine, Kyle spends his time either doing school work, playing music, reading history, or immersing himself in a good video game.

You can follow Kyle on Twitter @khady93.

6 Comments Join the Conversation →


  • Josh Killian

    Amazing episode! Jonathan Frakes’ return to Star Trek was certainly a welcome one! That Being Said, there were a few inconsistencies in this episode. First of all, it seems the producers of DSC have decided that Star Trek: Enterprise is NOT in fact cannon because of the whole USS Defiant reference. Second, another indication that DSC is a brand new timeline is the design of the Constitution class itself. While not as grotesquely over-proportioned as the “Kelvin Timeline” Enterprise, the design of this ship isn’t Prime Universe either

    On another note, CAN WE PLEASE KNOW ONCE AND FOR ALL IF TYLER IS VOQ?! All the mystery and secrecy around Tyler’s true identity is SO ANNOYING!!! GIVE IT A REST PEOPLE!! TELL US WHO HE IS REALLY!!!

    My rating for this episode: 4 out of 5 stars!

    • Kyle Alexander Hadyniak

      Hey Josh,

      Thanks for reading! I just wanted to point out that the Enterprise continuity is *not thrown out the window because of this episode. “Despite Yourself” takes place a number of years after we see the Defiant in Enterprise. And since we are still in the same Mirror Universe as before, we’ll only be learning what happened to the Defiant after the events of “In a Mirror, Darkly.” Fun stuff, indeed!

      • Josh Killian

        Thanks for the response, Kyle! I appreciate your answer to my comment AND the clarification you provided. For the most part, I really have enjoyed ST:DSC and certainly do want to see it Live Long and Prosper! Still, I do wish it was on TV though….Just sayin’….

    • Renita Sabrina

      Let’s stop by to see King Arthur: Legend Of The Sword and copy here web site >>> XMOVIEFOX.BLOGSPOT.COM

    • Tashya Maria

      Let’s stop by to see Woodshock >>> SONYPICTURES01.BLOGSPOT.COM

  • Vger64

    To Jonathan Frakes and Everyone involved in this latest Trek…. I applaud you no end!!! Star Trek LIVES!!!!!!!